Mutltiple PAP2Ts behind router?

[burris]

Thanks Burris. Like I mentioned in my original post, I acknowleged people successfully use VOIPo without any port forwarding, so I'm sorry I forced you to say your "it" one more time.

What happens if you leave your router firewall active? I know the router's NAT gives a lot of protection, and all the PCs in my house are running Zone or Kaspersky suites which include firewall. But I've got over 20 networked devices in the house (DVRs, printservers, PDAs, various A/V components with networking capabilities, etc), so especially for the non-PC devices, I'd prefer to keep the router's SPI firewall running if possible. I see that you run ASUS routers with ASUS firmware... I have a lot of experience with ASUS routers myself (I currently run a WL-500w and WL-500G Premium V2, and have been an ASUS mobo fan for about 8 years now, and started playing with their routers back in 2005). Neither of these are the routers I'm using at home now, and I eventually put WW-DRT on both of them, but I ran them both with the ASUS f/w for a couple months. Very reliable and sturdy, as you previously mentioned, but their firewall doesn't behave the same as other routers' firewalls. Not better or worse, just different. Did you have VOIPo problems if you left the ASUS firewall active? I guess I'm asking if running the two ATAs is what prompted you to disable the ASUS firewall?

Also, if I infer correctly (and I'm sorry if I'm wrong) you have DSL. I just recently switched in January from AT&T DSL to Comcast HSI (even with cable's wild througput swings during the day, the cable 16/2 tier still blows away my 6/768 DSL tier I had). My point is when I had DSL, I saw little to no probing in my router logs. But the second I switched to cable, there's a steady stream of probes- from China, Russia, other cable customers' bots, etc). It's the nature of the cable beast, but it makes me more hesitant to disable my router's SPI than if I was still on DSL.

Thanks again!
Frank

Why not leave it enabled and if you have no problems OK. If yo do have a problem, this might be the first place to look. I really don't remember why I had to remove it.

I may have mentioned that for me, DSL is far more reliable than Comcast. I have half the speed but 10 times the reliability. My real reason for switching to DSL was that in South Florida we have lots of storms, hurricanes and lightning. Comcast had a habit of going down with the least provocation, and since I have no land line, I was out of service too many times and for too long. With DSL, the BellSouth is far more reliable during storms, so along with a number of UPS boxes, I feel safer. Comcast had a 2Gb/month cap on newsgroups that I didn't like.
Also, I find that for me, VOIP works a lot better on DSL.

Let us know how it works out for you. Maybe be helpful to others.

Good Luck..

[Russell]

Fwiw, I've run multiple ATAs behind my $10 router with no port forwarding. Also, NAT is not disabled on the router.